MATE 664 Lecture 09
Atomic Models for Diffusion (II): Gas & Liquid Phases
- Slides 👉 Open presentation🗒️
- PDF version of course note 👉 Open in pdf
- Handwritten notes 👉 Open in pdf
Recap of Lecture 08
Key ideas from last lecture:
- Analytical solution to diffusion problems (infinite domain)
- Semi-infinite (half-half) solution
- Line / point source solution
- Superimposition method
- Separation of variables method (finite / bounded domain)
- Laplace transform (will not be covered in exam)
Learning outcomes
After this lecture, you will be able to:
- Recall the conditions behind the Einstein diffusion equation
- Understand why the Einstein relation is universal across states of matter
- Connect gas, liquid, and solid diffusion within a unified framework
- Derive Arrhenius-type diffusivity from a 1D potential well model
- Identify assumptions and missing physics in simple diffusion models
Recap: linking atomistic motion to diffusion
From last lecture:
- Diffusion emerges from random microscopic motion
- Mean squared displacement (MSD) is the key observable
- Einstein equation links MSD to macroscopic diffusivity
Einstein diffusion equation
Define MSD as the normalized second moment of concentration:
\[\begin{align} \langle R^2(t)\rangle &= \frac{\int_0^\infty r^2 c(r,t)\,4\pi r^2 dr} {\int_0^\infty c(r,t)\,4\pi r^2 dr} \end{align}\]Using solution to point source diffusion, Einstein showed:
- 3D: \(\langle R^2\rangle = 6Dt\)
- 2D: \(\langle R^2\rangle = 4Dt\)
- 1D: \(\langle R^2\rangle = 2Dt\)
Random-walk model solution to MSD
MSD in a 1D random-walk model is the expectance value of \(\text{Distance}^2\):
\[\begin{align} \langle R^2(t)\rangle &= N_{\tau} \langle r^2\rangle \\ &= \Gamma \tau \langle r^2\rangle \end{align}\]Linking Einstein equation to random walk model
- Two methods should give the same result for \(\langle R^2(t)\rangle\)
- \(t\) in Einstein’s method is just \(\tau\) in random walk model
Compare (1D case):
\[\begin{align} \langle R^2(\tau)\rangle &= 2 D \tau \\ &= \Gamma \tau \langle r^2\rangle \end{align}\]Results for diffusivity \(D\)
\[\begin{align} D &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{6};\quad \text{3D} \\ &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{4};\quad \text{2D}\\ &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{2};\quad \text{1D} \end{align}\]In-depth analysis of microscopic \(D\) formula
\[\begin{align} D &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{6};\quad \text{3D} \\ &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{4};\quad \text{2D}\\ &= \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{2};\quad \text{1D} \end{align}\]Units:
- Diffusivity \(D\): \(\text{m}^2/\text{s}\)
- Mean jump length \(\langle r^2\rangle\): \(\text{m}\)
- Frequency \(\Gamma\): \(\text{s}^{-1}\)
- The macroscopic diffusivity is directly linked to microscopic movements!
Application of microscopic diffusivity equation
The master equation for microscopic diffusivity becomes
\[\begin{align} \boxed{ D = \frac{\Gamma \langle r^2\rangle}{6} f } \end{align}\]Applicable fields?
- Gas? ✅ – kinetic theory of gases
- Liquid? ✅ – Stokes-Einstein equation
- Amorphous material / polymers? ✅ – Modified Stokes-Einstein
- Solid? ✅ – various mechanism
Case 1: gas-phase diffusivity
\(\Gamma\) and \(r^2\) in gas phase can be solved using statistical mechanics treatment (kinetic theory). Some important results:
- Average velocity \(\langle u \rangle\) (\(m\): molecular weight)
\[ \langle u \rangle = \sqrt{\frac{8 k_B T}{\pi m}} \]
- Mean free path \(\lambda\) (\(n\): number density; \(d\): molecular diameter)
\[ \lambda = \frac{1}{\sqrt{2} \pi d n} \]
- Relation to microscopic parameters:
Gas-phase diffusivity: \(T, p\) relations
Using ideal gas law \(p = n k_B T\), it is possible to show
\[\begin{align} D &\propto \sqrt{T} (\frac{p}{k_B T})^{-1} \\ &= \frac{T^{3/2}}{p} \end{align}\]Methods like the Chapman-Enskog theory has such power laws with \(T\) and \(p\), and can predict \(D\) in gas phase within 10% error compared to experimental results.
Case 2: liquid-phase diffusivity
Recall the macroscopic model for diffusivity (Einstein relation) that links mobility \(M\) to diffusivity \(D\) using steady-state motion of a particle in a frictous fluid:
\[\begin{align} D &= M k_B T \\ M &= \frac{\text{[velocity]}}{\text{[driving force]}} \end{align}\]At steady-state, the driving force \(F_{d}\) equals the opposite of dragging force \(f_{drag}\). In the linear regime, we can often model \(f_{drag} = k_{f} v\), where \(k_{f}\) is the friction factor.
We will see the mobility treatment is essentially the same as \(D \propto \Gamma \langle r^2 \rangle\).
Newton’s equation for transport in viscous liquid
Goal: from dynamic equation of the system –> expressions for \(\Gamma\) and \(\langle r^2 \rangle\)
Governing Equation
Transport in viscous liquid: results
We’re more interested in the average displacement \(x^2\). In 1D system it follows:
\[\begin{align} \langle \frac{\partial (x^2)}{\partial t} \rangle &= \frac{2 k_B T}{k_f} \\ \langle x^2 \rangle &= \frac{2 k_B T}{k_f} t \end{align}\]Which means \(\langle x^2 \rangle\) linearly increases with time!
Linking diffusivity results
For 3D system where \(x, y, z\) motions are independent, \(\langle R^2 \rangle = \langle x^2 \rangle + \langle y^2 \rangle + \langle z^2 \rangle = \frac{6 k_B T}{k_f} t\). We can reuse the result \(\langle R^2 \rangle = 6 Dt\):
\[\begin{align} D &= \frac{\langle R^2 \rangle}{6 t} \\ &= \frac{\cancel{6} k_B T \cancel{t}}{k_f \cancel{6} \cancel{t}} \\ &= \frac{k_B T}{k_f} \\ &= M k_B T \end{align}\]We’ve arrived at the macroscopic conclusion! The last expression uses the relation \(M = f_k^{-1}\).
Diffusivity in liquid: Stokes-Einstein equation
When the mobility \(M\) uses the Stokes equation \(f_{drag} = 6 \pi \eta R v\), we arrive at the Stokes-Einstein equation:
\[\begin{align} D &= M k_B T\\ &= \frac{\cancel{v}}{6 \pi \eta R \cancel{v}} k_B T \\ &= \frac{k_B T}{6 \pi \eta R} \end{align}\]- Viscosity \(\eta\) (unit \(\text{Pa}\cdot \text{s}\)) typically follows thermal activation \(\eta \propto \exp(A/T)\)
- What about the radius \(R\) for non-spherical objects?
Polymer diffusivity models
In linear polymer with \(N\) repeating units, each having characteristic lenth \(b\), the self-diffusivity follows:
\[\begin{align} D^* &= \frac{k_B T}{6 \pi \eta R_h} \end{align}\]and the hydrodynamic radius \(R_h\) scales as
\[\begin{align} R_h &\sim \begin{cases} N^{3/5} b & \text{good solvent} \\ N^{1/2} b & \theta \text{theta solvent} \end{cases} \end{align}\]- Good solvent: polymer–solvent interaction is favorable
- Theta solvent: polymer–solvent interaction is neutral (like ideal chain)
Case 3: diffusivity in solids
The relation \(D = \frac{\Gamma r^2}{6} f\) can be applied to diffusion in solids, if we know the type of mechanism
Some terminologies:
- Mechanism: an abstraction of atomic motion in crystals
- Sites: available spaces for atoms to move in / out
- Substitutional site: an atom replaces the position of another
- Interstitial site: an atom is inserted into the spaces between two atomic sites
- Barrier: when moving atoms in either substitional or interstitial mechanisms, the inter-atomic potential causes moving atoms to “feel” higher energy states
Key of diffusion theory: barrier ⇔ diffusivity
Solid diffusion: potential well model
The easiest model to illustrate the effect of an energy barrier is the potential well model. Our goal is still to find:
- Expression for \(\Gamma\), \(r^2\) (and optionally \(f\))
- Derive \(D = \frac{\Gamma r^2}{6} f\)
Step-function potential well model
Key results:
- Attempted frequency \(\nu\) (due to kinetic energy)
\[ \nu = \sqrt{\frac{k_B T}{2 \pi m}} \frac{1}{L_w} \]
- Cross-barrier frequency \(\Gamma'\)
\[ \Gamma' = \nu e^{-\frac{E^a}{k_B T}} \]
- Diffusivity
More complex landscape: parabolic well model
- Near the bottom of well, \(E(x) = E_{min} + \frac{\beta}{2} (x - x_{min})^2\)
- More realistic for interatomic potential (similar to springs)
- Modifications from the step-function well:
Again, the jumping frequency is related to thermal activation.
What is missing in this picture?
- One-particle energy landscape –> many-body landscape
- Static potential –> configuration-dependent \(E(\vec{x})\)
- Energy only –> entropic effect in many-body system
- Uncorrelated jump –> correlated movement
- Single jump event –> symmetry multiplication in lattice
Case 3: diffusion in many-body potential landscape
- Different modes of movement co-exist
- General solution still follows the Boltzmann-distribution-like equation (see KOM eq. 7.25 )
- Attempt frequency related to jumping angular momentum: \(\nu = \omega_J / (2 \pi)\)
- Activation entropy \(S^m\) related to all angular momenta in the system.
In-depth discussion about \(D\)
- Arrhenius-type equation:
\[ D = D_0 \exp(- \frac{H^m}{k_B T}) \]
In the plot only activation enthalpy relevant, entropic effect largely ignored
Activation enthalpy can be readily obtained from modern quantum chemistry / density functional theory calculation
Theoretical calculation for \(D\) covered in later part of the course
Summary
In this lecture we covered the following topics:
- Link between micro- and macroscopic diffusivity descriptions through the Einstein equation
- Master equation \(D = \dfrac{\Gamma r^2}{6}f\)
- Case studies of diffusivities in gas and liquid phases
- Derivation of Arrhenius diffusivity equation using the potential well model